News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Wild goose chase 

Wild goose chase

02 Jun, 2009 09:01 AM
TAREE Local Court has heard how a Wingham woman falsely conscripted police in order to make a man's life a 'living hell'.

Kundibakh Close resident, Narelle Christine Webb, abused almost $10,000 in police resources and 10 hours of the domestic violence court assistance scheme when she fraudulently initiated 11 police investigations in November and December last year.

Webb's false allegations of harassment and intimidation saw an innocent man arrested twice, issued with an interim apprehended domestic violence order and charged with five counts of stalking.

The court ordered 34-year-old Webb to compensate police after it was found she had led them on a 'wild goose chase' in order to serve her own means.

Webb made her first fraudulent report to police on November 11 last year. She attended Taree Police Station where she told officers she had received threatening phone calls from the male victim. Webb's allegations saw an interim apprehended domestic violence order served on the male victim.

Webb made similar reports to police over the next three weeks. These reports included:

* November 17: Police drove to Webb's home in Wingham after she alleged the victim had made threatening phone calls to her. The ensuing investigation saw the victim arrested and charged with three breaches of the ADVO and one count of stalk and intimidate. He was later released on bail.

* November 22: Webb attended Taree Police Station where she alleged the victim had further breached the ADVO in the form of threatening phone calls.

* November 24: Webb again attended Taree Police Station to allege further breaches on the part of the victim. The victim was again arrested and released on bail pending further investigations.

* November 25: Webb attended Taree Police Station where she alleged the victim had sent her threatening text messages. Police initiated an investigation through Kempsey Police and telecommunication providers.

* November 26: Webb attended Taree Police Station to report further threatening text messages from the victim.

* November 27: Webb again attended Taree Police Station where she showed officers 15 voice and text messages on her phone. She told police they were all from the victim's phone.

* December 3: Webb provided a signed statement to police stating she had received a threatening message from the victim. The ensuing investigation saw the victim arrested the next day and charged with seven breaches of the ADVO and four counts of stalk and intimidate. The victim was initially refused bail, but entered into court bail with the condition he hand in all of his mobile phones. Police noticed none of the phones the victim handed in matched the number Webb had given police.

* December 5: Webb attended Taree Police Station where she alleged the victim had sent her more threatening messages from his phone.

* December 6 and 7: Webb contacted police to report further threatening messages from the victim.

It was at this point police began to doubt Webb's claims. Information received from telecommunication providers, accompanied with the alibis from the victim, pointed towards the fact that the victim could not have had such an intimate knowledge of Webb's movements.

Police questioned Webb about her claims at Taree Police Station on December 9. Police enquiries led officers to search Webb's car, which was parked in Albert Street outside the police station. Police uncovered a mobile phone in the centre console of the car. It was the same phone the male victim had allegedly been using to send abusive messages to Webb. Police checked the phone and found that Webb had sent 42 messages to herself over an extended period of time. Webb was arrested immediately.

Webb pleaded guilty in Taree Local Court on May 26 to 11 counts of making a false accusation with the intent to subject another person to investigation.

The court heard Webb's actions used up an estimated 10 hours of the domestic violence court assistance scheme, 15 police man hours and the time of 12 different police officers. It was also revealed that police arranged alternate accommodation for Webb on several occasions due to her alleged fears for her safety.

"Ms Webb, sometimes the reason why people become involved in a criminal activity is difficult to determine," said magistrate Shaughan McCosker. "Sometimes it is blatantly clear. I have no doubt in my mind that you planned, contrived, and executed this plan to make (the victim's) life a living hell.

"You led police on a wild goose chase. You abused police's severely limited resources. You cannot conscript police for your own personal revenge."

Mr McCosker ordered Webb to complete 200 hours community service and placed her on a five-year good behaviour bond. Webb was also ordered to pay $9533.50 compensation to police for using their resources.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB43 plans 1%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 5%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 3%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press



Manning River Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...